Connect with Isthmus:         Newsletters 
Friday, December 26, 2014  |   Madison, WI: 36.0° F  
CITIZEN DAVE: Thoughts and ideas about city building from Madison's former mayor
Share on Google+
Citizen Dave: Compromise and flexibility are at the heart of America
on (1) Comment

Today is the 225th anniversary of the signing of the United States Constitution. It is the product of a long summer of compromises, and has proved to be a flexible document, adaptable to issues that couldn't have been imagined when it was written.

So, it's ironic that the current movement that likes to think of itself as the defenders of the Constitution is so adamantly opposed to any compromise, and believes that the document should be set in amber.

The tea party movement is not the defender of our constitution, but the very antithesis of what it stands for.

Compromise and flexibility are at the center of that document. It wasn't always pretty. In fact, sometimes it was pretty ugly. The southern states, which didn't want to recognize slaves as human beings much less allow them to vote, cynically wanted to count them in their populations so that they could get more representation in Congress. The compromise was to count the slave population as three-fifths of what it really was.

By any measure that was unprincipled. If slaves were property, then how could they be counted even partially as human beings? By locking in higher representation for the slave states, the Constitution guaranteed a long fight to end the peculiar institution. But it worked to get the document approved. If legislating is like sausage making, then the Constitution is smorgasbord.

And the entire issue of slavery was so divisive that the Founders simply punted on it. As the historian Joseph Ellis has pointed out, they might be forgiven some of their other political incorrectness on grounds that they were simply reflecting the mores of their time, but they knew slavery was wrong and they failed to end it. So, it was finally abolished after a bloody civil war, and so the Constitution's failure to deal with our nation's great original sin echoes down to today.

So, the Constitution wasn't a perfect document. It was born with deep flaws but it survives because it contained the means for evolution and change -- it can be amended, and it can be dragged into the present day through court interpretations of its meaning.

On this anniversary, it's good to remind ourselves that compromise and flexibility are at the very heart of the United States of America. Those who disdain those things, whether of the right or left, are truly un-American.

Share on Google+
Show 1 Comments

Log in or register to comment

Promotions Contact us Privacy Policy Jobs Newsletters RSS
Collapse Photo Bar